Coffee-Mate Italian Sweet Cream Recipe

Are you looking for a homemade replica of your favorite coffee creamer? We’ve got it handled with this Coffee-Mate Italian Sweet Cream Recipe!

Free of processed ingredients and additives, this Coffee-Mate Italian Sweet Cream Recipe only requires four ingredients. The process of making this homemade creamer is borderline effortless! All that is required is heating up the ingredients, stirring every now and then allowing the creamer to cool before using it in your favorite coffee or latte combo. If you’re interested in how to make other coffee creamer variations, we’ve added a list of small changes that can be made in this recipe to alter to a new flavoring of your own choosing!

For more information on how to make this unforgettably tasty Coffee-Mate Italian Sweet Cream Recipe, continue reading! 

Jump to Recipe

Why Making Creamer At Home Is Ideal

There are plenty of reasons why making food at home is more ideal than going out to eat. One of the most essential reasons is controlling what goes into your food as many companies, food chains, and restaurants will sneak in addictive additives that keep people coming back for more. When looking at Coffee Mate’s Italian sweet cream creamer nutrition facts, there will be added sugars that are unnecessary for a sweet creamer option like this. 

Coffee-Mate’s Italian Sweet Cream is one of those products. First, let’s take a look at the ingredients listed for Coffee-Mate’s Italian Sweet Cream.

Ingredients:

  • Water
  • Sugar
  • Coconut Oil
  • 2% Or Less Of:
    • Sodium Caseinate (A Milk Derivative)
    • Dipotassium Phosphate
    • Monoglycerides
    • Diglycerides
    • Sucralose
    • Natural Flavors
    • Artificial Flavors

Now, take a look at our recipe for Coffee Mate’s Italian Sweet Cream Recipe…it only has four ingredients. Four! There are loads of unnecessary ingredients in this storebought creamer that can otherwise be easily made at home with cleaner and fewer ingredients. 

 italian sweet cream creamer nutrition facts

Other Delectable Flavor Options Using Extracts

Hazelnut Extract

For all the coffee lovers with a fancy for nutty flavors, adding hazelnut extract to your homemade creamer recipe is ideal. Often highly sought after and marketed during the winter months, hazelnut is an incredibly popular flavor option due to its welcoming nutty, creamy, and sometimes buttery-tasting notes. This flavor option can easily be conducted in the comfort of your own home by replacing the almond and vanilla extract with the hazelnut extract for a fun, nutty coffee creamer alternative.

Chocolate Extract

Who needs a reason for more chocolate at this point? It’s such a popular flavor option circling the globe, it’s no surprise that there’s an extract flavoring option for it!

To make chocolate extract, cocoa beans are infused with an alcohol solution similar to how vanilla extract is made. The chocolate extract is soothingly powerful in its signature chocolatey taste and aroma, while also being 100% natural. Sometimes a chocolate creamer option is necessary to soothe the soul as much as the cravings! 

Maple Extract

Empowering the notably sweet taste of maple syrup, maple extract is a great replacement for maple sugar or even pure maple syrup!

The process of making maple extract includes using the evaporated sap of maple trees, which have a notoriously strong and sweet flavor. Whether it be a maple bacon coffee concoction or a maple pecan latte, maple extract makes for a wonderfully sweet addition as a coffee creamer option. 

 What cream is best in coffee?

Pecan Extract

Presenting a superior buttery and sweet flavor, pecan extract protrudes a delicious, mouthwatering aroma. Add this nutty extract flavor to your creamer for a tasty coffee tree option! Combine with maple extract for a maple pecan latte or coffee to celebrate the incoming holidays or simply enjoy the powerful combo. 

What You Will Need To Make This Coffee-Mate Italian Sweet Cream Recipe

Using the same creamer over and over again can get boring real quick. It can especially be agitating noting all the excessive inclusion of additives or processed ingredients listed on the backside of your favorite creamer!

 This clean and delicious Coffee-Mate Italian Sweet Cream Recipe is free of unnecessary ingredients—there are only four! All it requires is heating up the ingredients, stirring them together, and then voila, your own homemade replica of your favorite creamer! 

Ingredients: 

  • 2 Cups Milk
  • 1 Teaspoon Vanilla Extract
  • 1 Teaspoon Almond Extract
  • 1 Can Sweetened Condensed Milk

Equipment:

  • Can Opener
  • Measuring Utensils
  • Measuring Cup
  • Storage Container (Sealable)
  • Medium Saucepan
  • Whisk

 What does Italian sweet cream Coffee Mate taste like?

Step By Step Instructions To Make This Coffee-Mate Italian Sweet Cream Recipe

Step 1: Set Up The Saucepan

Place the medium saucepan on an available burner on the stovetop. 

Step 2: Use The Can Opener

For the next step, you will need to first apply this step. Use the can opener to open the sweetened condensed milk.

Step 3: Combine Both Milk Ingredients In The Saucepan

Pour the milk and sweetened condensed milk into the medium saucepan. Whisk to combine. 

Step 4: Simmer

Raise the heat to bring the contents in the saucepan to a simmer. Stir the contents frequently with the whisk. 

Step 5: Turn Off The Heat

When the contents begin to steam, it’s time to turn off the heat. Remove the pan from the burner.

Step 6: Add Both Of The Extracts

Now that the saucepan has been removed from the burner, it’s time to add the extracts. Pour in the vanilla extract and the almond extract. Whisk to stir to combine with the other ingredients. 

Step 7: Cool The Creamer

Before proceeding to any other steps, allow the creamer to cool. This can take anywhere from 5 minutes and on. 

Step 8: Chill The Creamer

Once the creamer has cooled, store the Coffee-Mate Italian Sweet Cream in an airtight container. Place in the refrigerator to store and allow to chill until ready to serve.

Step 9: Serve And Enjoy!

Serve your Coffee-Mate Italian Sweet Cream with your favorite coffee or espresso drink combos. Enjoy! 

Tips And Tricks

If stored properly in an airtight container in the refrigerator, this Coffee-Mate Italian Sweet Cream Recipe will have a shelf life of up to two weeks. 

Servings And Preparation Time

Preparation Time  Cook Time Servings
5 Minutes 5 Minutes  30

Conclusion

Did you enjoy this recipe? Make sure to leave a comment below to tell us what you think or if you have any questions. Don’t forget to share this article for this Coffee-Mate Italian Sweet Cream Recipe that pairs amazingly well with your favorite coffee or espresso drink combos! 

Tag us on social media with your finished product!

FAQs

What is Italian sweet cream used for?

It is an indulgent creamer flavoring for coffee drinkers.

What does Italian sweet cream Coffee-Mate taste like?

Some people have likened the taste of Coffee Mate's Italian Sweet Cream to the inside of a cannoli.

What cream is best in coffee?

Heavy cream and half-and-half are popular cream options for coffee or creamer recipes.

Coffee-Mate Italian Sweet Cream Recipe

Coffee-Mate Italian Sweet Cream Recipe

Recipeska
Using the same creamer over and over again can get boring real quick. It can especially be agitating noting all the excessive inclusion of additives or processed ingredients listed on the backside of your favorite creamer!  This clean and delicious Coffee-Mate Italian Sweet Cream Recipe is free of unnecessary ingredients---there are only four! All it requires is heating up the ingredients, stirring them together, and then voila, your own homemade replica of your favorite creamer! 
Prep Time 5 mins
Cook Time 5 mins
Total Time 10 mins
Course Drinks
Cuisine American
Servings 30

Equipment

  • Can Opener
  • Measuring Utensils
  • Measuring Cup
  • Storage Container (Sealable)
  • Medium Saucepan
  • Whisk

Ingredients
  

  • 2 Cups Milk
  • 1 Teaspoon Vanilla Extract
  • 1 Teaspoon Almond Extract
  • 1 Can Sweetened Condensed Milk

Instructions
 

  • Place the medium saucepan on an available burner on the stovetop.
  • For the next step, you will need to first apply this step. Use the can opener to open the sweetened condensed milk.
  • Pour the milk and sweetened condensed milk into the medium saucepan. Whisk to combine.
  • Raise the heat to bring the contents in the saucepan to a simmer. Stir the contents frequently with the whisk.
  • When the contents begin to steam, it’s time to turn off the heat. Remove the pan from the burner.
  • Now that the saucepan has been removed from the burner, it’s time to add the extracts. Pour in the vanilla extract and the almond extract. Whisk to stir to combine with the other ingredients.
  • Before proceeding to any other steps, allow the creamer to cool. This can take anywhere from 5 minutes and on.
  • Once the creamer has cooled, store the Coffee-Mate Italian Sweet Cream in an airtight container. Place in the refrigerator to store and allow to chill until ready to serve.
  • Serve your Coffee-Mate Italian Sweet Cream with your favorite coffee or espresso drink combos. Enjoy!

Notes

  • If stored properly in an airtight container in the refrigerator, this Coffee-Mate Italian Sweet Cream Recipe will have a shelf life of up to two weeks. 
Keyword coffee-mate italian sweet cream recipe, italian sweet cream creamer nutrition facts, What cream is best in coffee?, What does Italian sweet cream Coffee Mate taste like?, What is Italian sweet cream used for?