Before continuing on to any of the next steps, preheat the Traeger. Set the temperature to 225 F to preheat for 15 minutes with the lid closed. If desiring the most flavor possible from this recipe, use the Super Smoke option.
In the small mixing bowl, pour the salt and pepper into the bowl. Mix together to combine.
Using the mixture in the small mixing bowl, season the tri-tip. Make sure to season all sides of the tri-tip.
It’s time to cook the tri-tip. Insert the probe into the thickest section of the tri-tip, then place the tri-tip onto the grill grates. Shut the lid of the Traeger to cook.
Now that the tri-tip is cooking in the Traeger, cook the tri-tip for 60-90 minutes. The internal temperature of the tri-tip should reach 130 F.
After the tri-tip has reached 130 F for the internal temperature, remove the tri-tip from the Traeger. Use foil to wrap the tri-tip completely.
Raise the heat of the Traeger to 450 F.
Before continuing on to the next step, allow the Traeger to preheat until it reaches 450 F. This can take around 15 minutes.
Wait until the Traeger has preheated to 450 F before following up with this step. Once the Traeger has reached 450 F, remove the foil surrounding the tri-tip.
Insert the probe back into the tri-tip. Use the tongs to place the tri-tip on the grill. For 4 minutes, sear each side of the tri-tip.
Use the tongs to remove the seared and cooked tri-tip from the Traeger. Allow the tri-tip to cool for about 10 minutes.
Serve warm, using a sharp knife to slice against the grain. Enjoy!